Five questions about how your work is shaped, and one of three answers: flat-rate service pricing, construction takeoff, or both. It shows which answers drove the result, so you can argue with the reasoning instead of just the verdict.
It does not recommend a product and it does not invent a price. The table below carries only what each vendor publishes on its own page. Two of the six publish nothing, and that is shown as quote-gated with no figure attached.
What each vendor publishes
| Product | Category | What the vendor publishes | Source |
|---|---|---|---|
| FastEST (FastPIPE) | Estimating / job costing | published
|
FastEST, Inc., read |
| Knowify | Estimating / job costing | published, with a gap
|
Knowify, read |
| Jobber | Field service platform | published
|
Jobber, read |
| Housecall Pro | Field service platform | published, with a gap
|
Housecall Pro, read |
| FieldPulse | Field service platform | quote-gated
|
FieldPulse, read |
| ServiceTitan | Field service platform | quote-gated
|
ServiceTitan, read |
A row marked quote-gated carries no number because the vendor publishes none. Figures reported by third-party comparison sites are unverified and are not printed here.
Compare a quote you were given
Two of the products above will only tell you a price on a call. Type what you were quoted and it is put on the same 36-month footing as the published ones. Everything in this table is your input. Nothing is seeded, and a blank stays blank rather than counting as zero.
| What you were quoted | One-off | Per month | Per year | 36 months |
|---|
Total = one-off + (per month × 36) + (per year × 3). The formula is printed because a total whose arithmetic is hidden is not checkable.
How this decides, and what it refuses to decide
Each question carries a declared weight: where the price comes from counts 3, job length, who prices and competitive bidding count 2 each, and progress billing counts 1. An answer of “both” adds half its weight to each side. The result is the side with more weight, unless the two are within 25% of each other, in which case the answer is both rather than a coin toss.
Three limits, stated rather than discovered. With fewer than three questions answered
it returns NOT_ENOUGH_ANSWERS and no verdict — an incomplete questionnaire producing a
confident answer is the failure this site exists to avoid. The weights are a stated editorial judgement,
not a fitted model, and they are printed above so you can disagree with them. And it never ranks products
inside a category, because ranking software by how well it works would require having operated it, and
this site has not.